Home/OTHER/INDIA/Article
OTHER

Eminent citizens reject 'One Nation, One Election' initiative, citing federal risks

At Constitution Club of India in New Delhi, former Election Commissioner Ashok Lavasa raised concerns that approximately 16 crore citizens could face disenfranchisement from electoral roll revisions. Participants highlighted an urgent need for reforms aimed at safeguarding citizens' rights and preserving integrity of India's democratic process.

BRIC Team
BRIC Team
Jul 4, 2026 · 1 min read · 6 views
Eminent citizens reject 'One Nation, One Election' initiative, citing federal risks

Key Takeaways

  • Approximately 16 crore citizens may have been disenfranchised due to the Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls, according to former Election Commissioner Ashok Lavasa.
  • Former Supreme Court judges warned that the constitutional right to vote is being compromised amid a growing crisis of trust in the Election Commission of India.
  • G.K. Pillai emphasized that the 2027 Population Census will significantly impact delimitation, women’s reservation, and welfare allocation in India.
  • Participants at the conclave argued that the proposed ‘One Nation, One Election’ initiative threatens the autonomy of State Assemblies and federal structure.
  • Concerns were raised about the lack of transparency in the Election Commission's handling of electoral records, including Form 17C and CCTV footage.

Concerns Rise Over Federal Structure Amid Electoral Reform Debate

On Saturday,a significant assembly of retired civil servants,judicial figures,legal experts,and leaders from social movements gathered to discuss impacts of new electoral proposals . This meeting sparked debate over risks of synchronizing elections nationwide,which participants warned could threaten India's federal integrity.

Ex-Election Commissioner Ashok Lavasa stood out with his serious concerns about Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls. He revealed an estimated 160 million voters might be affected,questioning transparency in removal of names from lists. Lavasa urged Election Commission of India (ECI) to clarify how many removed due to migration versus ineligibility,especially given Supreme Court's order for ECI to submit names to Foreigners Tribunals .

Talks also focused on decline in citizenship rights . Participants worried Indian passport is now just a travel document,raising anxiety over citizenship security. They agreed proving citizenship has unfairly shifted to individuals,adding to public distress.

Former Supreme Court judges echoed these concerns,stating fundamental right to vote is under threat. They warned of broader implications of proposed reforms,highlighting growing distrust in ECI and potential erosion of citizens' rights. Participants demanded more transparency and accountability,noting challenges in accessing vital electoral documents and CCTV footage.

Former Union Home Secretary G.K. Pillai stressed need for transparent public input on upcoming caste census,calling it crucial for demographic insight in India. He noted 2027 Population Census will influence delimitation,women's reservations,and more. Pillai emphasized technology can boost efficiency,but success of censuses hinges on openness,community input,and careful execution.

Conclave participants unanimously pushed for urgent electoral reforms,demanding ECI accountability. They committed to fostering democracy that respects citizen rights and core principles. As election synchronization discussions continue,these voices highlight growing worries about preserving federal principles and essence of citizenship in India…

#India

Share this article

Related Articles

Labour Minister G. Vivek Venkatswamy advocates judicial reform to enhance justice delivery system

Labour Minister G. Vivek Venkatswamy advocates judicial reform to enhance justice delivery system

G. Vivek Venkatswamy, Labour Minister of India, urged for urgent judicial reforms at National Legal Conclave held at FAPCCI in Andhra Pradesh. He cautioned that a weakened judiciary might result in an overreaching government, stressing importance of maintaining balance between executive and judiciary.

BRIC Team

Jul 4, 20260
DMK president M.K. Stalin vows party will rise from setbacks in new address

DMK president M.K. Stalin vows party will rise from setbacks in new address

M.K. Stalin, president of DMK, expressed confidence on Saturday that his party would emerge resilient from challenges, comparing its comeback to a phoenix. He highlighted DMK's distinctive organizational strength and urged for collective efforts to craft its narrative alongside Tamil Nadu's history for the next century.

BRIC Team

Jul 4, 20262 views
Former AIADMK ministers and ex-MLAs meet Chief Minister Vijay in Panaiyur

Former AIADMK ministers and ex-MLAs meet Chief Minister Vijay in Panaiyur

Former Ministers and ex-MLAs from AIADMK gathered with Chief Minister C. Joseph Vijay at TVK headquarters in Panaiyur on Saturday to talk about their roles in ruling party. This meeting was significant for new members, who received assurances of party postings after discussions with Mr. Vijay.

BRIC Team

Jul 4, 20262 views
Mourners gather in Tehran for former supreme leader's funeral

Mourners gather in Tehran for former supreme leader's funeral

Tehran is getting ready for the funeral of former supreme leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, who passed away after US and Israeli strikes four months ago. Millions are anticipated to join the burial in Mashhad next Thursday, highlighting Khamenei's enduring impact on Iran's political scene.

BRIC Team

Jul 4, 20262 views
FIFA World Cup 2026: Top Round of 16 matches to watch from July 4-7

FIFA World Cup 2026: Top Round of 16 matches to watch from July 4-7

Canada is set to take on Morocco on July 4 at Houston Stadium, looking for redemption after their 2-1 defeat in their last match. At the same time, France, with Kylian Mbappe at the helm, is eager to keep their strong momentum going against Paraguay, a team that successfully contained Germany's offense.

BRIC Team

Jul 4, 20261 views
Argentina defeats Cape Verde 3-2 to advance to Round of 16 in FIFA World Cup

Argentina defeats Cape Verde 3-2 to advance to Round of 16 in FIFA World Cup

Argentina triumphed over Cape Verde with a score of 3-2 in an exciting match at Miami Stadium on Saturday, earning a spot in Round of 16 at 2026 FIFA World Cup. Defending champions now prepare to take on Egypt as they aim to keep their title.

BRIC Team

Jul 4, 20261 views